She became angry with Penner, and a day after his betrayal, when she cut her thumb with a machete while cutting a coconut, she said that she was imagining the coconut was Penner's head.After alliance member Woodcock was eliminated, Shallow and Gentry found themselves fighting for survival.
As a juror, she cast her vote for eventual runner-up Ozzy Lusth.
Shallow was noted for being a flirt throughout the season.
Shallow then made a pact with Cirie Fields to go all the way to the Final Three with Kimmel.
After losing the third Immunity Challenge, Shallow was targeted by the opposing alliance, but her own alliance (now with Fields) succeeded in voting off strategic threat Chan.
However, Fields saw this as an opportunity to blindside physical threat Lusth instead, and she needed Shallow's help for it to work.